It's a bit clumpy when you put it on and it doesn't show up well. I think it might work better as an eyeshadow instead of eyelinerI use this more as creme eyeshadow than an eyeliner. It’s too clumpy as an eyeliner. I wanted it to work, it’s so pretty! But it’s not a great eyeliner.Difficult to use. Super thick. Not spreadable. Not worth returning it. Tossed it.I really wanted to love this, but it fell short. The color is great, don't get me wrong...but it does not apply smoothly. It is very thick and does not go on smoothly. Even when using an eyeliner brush it goes on thick and clumpy. I was really disappointed. This was purchased for me off of my wish list.This color is beautiful and so shinny! I love it! It is clumpy if you just try to pull some out on a brush but if you stir the amount you want to use in the jar fairly well with a firm-ish brush it will whip it up better then apply nice and smoothly. For the price, you can't beat it!Such a beautiful colour and effectThe product came old. Very dry, cannot use it at all. Very disappointed.